Bill Skarsgard took himself out of the Freddy Krueger conversation on Josh Horowitz’s Happy Sad Confused, the Nov. 5 episode timed to his new film The Mosquito Bowl. It matters because he is the only actor who has made a legacy horror villain profitable again this decade, and the studio hunting for its own glove-wearing dream hire just lost its favorite name without ever officially asking him.

Asked about villains, Skarsgard set the bar at newness, not nostalgia: “For a villain, it would have to be something that felt original to me, that was something that I hadn’t done before.” Then the line that traveled: “It’s not like, ‘Give me a shot at Freddy Krueger!’ You know what I mean? I feel kind of spent with those things. But villains can be really fun in different ways,” a quote Bloody Disgusting and SYFY both transcribed the same way.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7dyrwLAH6Mg

The role he just declined, politely and unasked, is Paramount Primal’s adaptation of Wes Craven’s 1984 screenplay, locked down in July with the Craven estate after a copyright quirk let the family reclaim the rights 35 years after the original’s release (the kind of clause studios usually only remember exists when it works against them). The rival version at Warner Bros., with Lee Cronin in talks to write and direct, died after Paramount Skydance closed its $110 billion purchase of Warner Bros. Discovery on Oct. 6, leaving Paramount Primal as the only company with a working Elm Street script.

As of Nov. 10, that project has no writer and no director attached, which is a bigger gap than any one actor’s no. The last time Freddy showed up on screen, the 2010 remake with Jackie Earle Haley opened to $32.9 million and finished at $115.7 million worldwide on a $35 million budget, a number that paid off the negative and ended the franchise anyway. Nobody has made a Freddy movie since.

What this probably means. Skarsgard saying no costs Paramount its easiest headline, not its timeline. There is no filmmaker attached to delay and no production calendar to miss. A label built to work from a 1984 script at a modest budget was never going to be the place that writes a check for a marquee star to put on the glove; it was always going to need someone the role makes famous, the way it made Robert Englund famous the first time.

Pennywise, meanwhile, is not going anywhere. Welcome to Derry was renewed for Season 2 in August, jumping to 1935 for the Bradley Gang massacre, and HBO Max slipped out a surprise 30-minute special, “A Story of Derry,” on Oct. 31. Showrunner Brad Caleb Kane has promised “a different kind of Pennywise, Pennywise the way you’ve never seen that character before.”

Englund, who wore the Freddy makeup across seven Elm Street films plus Freddy vs. Jason, has already laid out the actual hiring brief, whoever ends up filling it. His pick was “someone like a Doug Jones,” though his real preference runs further: “they probably should steer themselves to someone more unknown that doesn’t have to worry about following in my footsteps or anything else, just creating his own conception of the character.” Kevin Bacon only came up as a name Englund recalled the studio floating years back, and even he doubts it: “he probably wouldn’t be interested.”

“They gotta pick somebody that can go the distance,” Englund said. Paramount Primal still has not named anyone with the authority to make that call, and until it does, the glove has no hand.