Madden now owns the worst Rotten Tomatoes score of Christian Bale’s career, and the number was never going to hold still. CBR had it at 13% from 16 reviews as of Nov. 18, down from the 15% it carried a day earlier on just 13 reviews.
It matters because that figure is now attached to Bale’s name for good, even as the score itself keeps drifting. By Nov. 19 the Tomatometer had climbed to 19% from 26 reviews, with a 57% audience score pulled from the first hundred-plus ratings. The record stands regardless: Bale’s previous floor was 28% for Captain Corelli’s Mandolin, set in 2001, with his next-worst cluster landing at 29% for Exodus: Gods and Kings, 32% for Amsterdam and 33% for Terminator Salvation, according to ScreenRant’s accounting of his filmography.
The coincidence writes itself. Captain Corelli’s Mandolin starred Nicolas Cage, who is also the one buried in the fat suit and prosthetics in Madden, which means Bale’s two worst-reviewed credits share a co-star twenty-five years apart. (Bale has never built a safe filmography; this is what the record looks like when the swings keep connecting at roughly a 1-for-5 clip.)
The business explains the quiet rollout. Amazon MGM put a reported $75 million into the film, then moved its limited, awards-qualifying theatrical run from Nov. 11 to Nov. 18, the same day it hit Prime Video. The Numbers still lists the domestic gross as n/a. It is David O. Russell’s first feature since Amsterdam, which cost $80 million and returned $31 million worldwide. (John Mulaney, who plays EA founder Trip Hawkins, hosted Saturday Night Live the weekend before release and never brought the movie up.)
The trailer that drew most of the attention leans hard on Cage’s prosthetics and Bale’s bleached, receding hairline:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xzh7HzLXXpk
Critics largely let Bale off the hook. The A.V. Club’s Matt Donato wrote that “Bale is a fantastic Al Davis.” The Guardian’s Andrew Lawrence said Bale “more than justifies the makeup and costuming departments’ considerable efforts” to revive Davis. The Associated Press’ Jake Coyle found the film only “momentarily coheres,” usually when Kathryn Hahn’s Virginia Madden is talking. The Hollywood Reporter’s David Rooney was the loud exception, dismissing the two leads as giving “stunt acting from both principals”. ScreenRant’s Matthew Rudoy still found “fantastic chemistry” between the leads, and Variety’s Owen Gleiberman called the film “crafted just well enough to let you touch the buzz of Russell’s intelligence.”
What this probably means: the 13% belongs to the movie more than to its star. Cage absorbs the prosthetic jokes, Russell absorbs the tone complaints, and Bale, playing a supporting part, collects most of the compliments inside a wreck. Movie Opinions already reviewed the fumble and covered the same-night theatrical and Prime Video launch; this score is the number those pieces predicted, not a new verdict on the film.
The next date that matters for Bale has nothing to do with Madden. ScreenRant reports he is set to play Vincent Hanna, the role Al Pacino originated, in Michael Mann’s Heat 2, with filming expected to start this month. That one comes with a franchise attached. Madden came with a $75 million bill and a Wednesday release date nobody wanted to own alone.