The Movie Opinions Verdict Skip It

Madden is a skip. It wants to be a loud, big-hearted NFL buddy comedy about two men who can’t stop thinking about football, and it never decides what kind of movie it is long enough to land either half of that promise.

The scorecard is ugly. Rotten Tomatoes has the film at 13% from 15 reviews, after ScreenRant tracked a 15% debut from 13 reviews and flagged it as the lowest Rotten Tomatoes score of Christian Bale’s career, worse than Captain Corelli’s Mandolin’s 28%. That is the floor of Bale’s career, full stop.

David O. Russell has lost twice in a row with Bale in the lineup. Amsterdam cost roughly $80 million and made $14 million domestically. Madden reportedly cost $75 million.

Two expensive misfires in a row is not bad luck. It is a pattern a studio should have noticed before cutting the next check.

Amazon’s rollout treats the movie like something to get through rather than sell. It lands on Prime Video the same day it opens in a limited theatrical run on Nov. 18, rated R and running 110 minutes. Critics saw it Monday night, and the embargo lifted about 15 hours later. The poster has Cage and Bale flashing Super Bowl rings and no mention of Russell anywhere on it. A publicist introducing the press screening reportedly said, “Please enjoy Nicolas Cage’s ‘Madden’!” That is a studio quietly telling the room not to blame the director.

Rotten Tomatoes files the movie under Biography, Comedy, Drama, Sports, and the trailer sold exactly that: two loud men who love each other and love football more.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xzh7HzLXXpk

What actually shows up on screen is a costume stunt standing in for a performance. Cage wore 30 pounds of prosthetics on top of 25 pounds he gained for the part, and the padding never stops announcing itself. The Hollywood Reporter’s David Rooney wrote that Cage is “encased in a fat suit so bulky he looks like a line drawing out of Family Guy.” Variety’s Owen Gleiberman went further, comparing him to “Jiminy Glick playing John Candy” and calling the performance “two parts impersonation, one part Nicolas Cage kabuki.” Prosthetics are supposed to be a door into a character. Here they’re the whole joke, and a joke is a thin foundation for a leading man.

The supporting cast is where the movie finally breathes. Bale plays Raiders owner Al Davis with a locked jaw and a Brooklyn accent that sticks, and he vanishes into the role more completely than Cage ever does into Madden. Kathryn Hahn gives Virginia Madden real warmth as a wife who wants a husband instead of a legend. John Mulaney shows up as EA founder Trip Hawkins, and Sienna Miller is in there somewhere as Carol Davis.

One reviewer found a version of this film worth defending. ScreenRant’s Matthew Rudoy gave it 6 out of 10, praising the leads for “fantastic chemistry that successfully makes Davis and Madden’s friendship the heart of the movie.” He’s right. That friendship is the movie Madden should have made, start to finish.

Instead Russell keeps spinning the dial. Mockumentary cutaways interrupt scenes. A telestrator scribbles plays across the footage for no reason anyone can explain. The A.V. Club’s Matt Donato wrote that Russell “directs Cage as if Madden were sketch comedy,” and The Hollywood Reporter’s review ends with a single line that doubles as a warning: “Should come with a concussion warning.” A buddy comedy can survive a few hard hits. A film also trying to be a family drama cannot take that many, and the jokes keep landing on the tender scenes while the sincerity lands on the bits.

Then the second half trades the two men for a video game. Rudoy, even in his defense of the film, noted that the story “struggles in the second half once the video game development takes over,” and it’s hard to manufacture stakes around a product everyone in the audience already knows became a hit.

None of this will bother everyone. Gleiberman says the movie will appeal “mostly to sports fanatics of a certain age,” and that’s fair. NFL diehards who want the turducken of telestrator gags and Cage completists logging one more transformation will get what they came for.

Everyone else has somewhere better to be. A $75 million comedy about the most beloved man in football, sent to streaming with the director’s name scrubbed off the poster, already knows what it is. Skip it.