The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping is worth a theater ticket, but only if the book is already on the shelf. Newcomers should stay home.
This is the sixth film in a series that long ago stopped pretending each chapter stands on its own, and it runs 158 minutes, the longest in the franchise, a full minute past The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes. That number is not a flex. By the third act it is the whole review.
The trailer promised a sharper, angrier prequel than Snakes. The reviews say it mostly delivered one, then ran out of road.
Rotten Tomatoes opened the film at 70% from 61 reviews, level with both Mockingjay films, ahead of Snakes at 64%, and well behind The Hunger Games at 85% and Catching Fire at 90%. By Tuesday afternoon the same page had slid to 69% from 62 reviews.
Rotten Tomatoes posted the embargo-lift number itself:
https://x.com/RottenTomatoes/status/2122705935759990797
Metacritic tells the same story with more texture. The film sits at 56 from 27 reviews, split 14 positive, 11 mixed and two negative, with RogerEbert.com the top score at 88 and TheWrap at 83. That is not a rout. It is a franchise entry that split its critics clean down the middle, which beats what Snakes managed two years ago.
The best set piece in the movie is the reaping itself, and it works because of what the film does with the broadcast. Plutarch Heavensbee, played by Jesse Plemons, runs the cameras, and what Panem actually watches at home is a curated lie. Variety lays it out plainly: “What the viewers see at home, from the opening ceremonies onward, is the papered-over fake-news version, with awkward incidents left on the cutting-room floor.” Francis Lawrence, who has directed every installment since Catching Fire, stages the drawing of names like a public execution dressed up for television, and for one sequence the series finds a political idea sharper than anything in the last two prequels combined.
What the franchise needed from Sunrise on the Reaping was a lead worth the two and a half hours, and it got one. Joseph Zada plays Haymitch at 16, and The Hollywood Reporter built its entire review around his “star-making turn.” Deadline credits him with a “naïve, doe-eyed charm” that carries the film through most of its running time. Variety is less kind, comparing him to “a taller version of Christopher Atkins in The Blue Lagoon.” Both readings are correct, and the tension between them is the point: this Haymitch has to grow into Woody Harrelson’s ruined drunk 24 years down the line, and Zada’s job is to make the audience believe that collapse is coming.
The Capitol is where the movie spends everything else it has. Glenn Close plays Drusilla Sickle like a wax figure left too close to a heater, “grotesquely pulled-tight-in-the-face” in IndieWire’s phrase, with a look the outlet compares to Katherine Helmond’s Ida Lowry in Brazil. The Hollywood Reporter has her wheeled onstage “like Hannibal Lecter” in “what looks like a leather bumblebee costume.” Kieran Culkin’s younger Caesar Flickerman is mannered where Stanley Tucci was depraved, and Elle Fanning’s Effie Trinket is the one performance everyone agrees is simply fun to watch.
Jesse Plemons is the waste the franchise should answer for. He is the only character in the Capitol with a conscience and a plan, and IndieWire calls him “woefully underused.” Ralph Fiennes gets scraps as Snow. A camera operator with real stakes deserved more than a supporting function.
Then the arena opens, and the clock becomes the main character. Deadline rates the creatures “about as terrifying as being mauled to death by The Wonderful World of Disney” and calls the pacing “increasingly tedious.” That is the back half of the movie in one sentence: a franchise filling out the paperwork so the 2012 film can eventually happen.
Who should skip it: anyone who has not read Suzanne Collins’ novel. IndieWire calls the film “a dreary slog, another death-march ‘They Shoot Horses, Don’t They?’ riff with a pretty Gen Z cast.” The Guardian’s Peter Bradshaw goes further, writing that it “has no actual interest and no authentic reason to exist, other than to gouge an income stream out of its fanbase.” Deadline supplies the line that will follow this one around for years: the series “has reached its High School Musical moment where everyone gets a participation prize.”
The defense is on the record too, and it is not nothing. The Hollywood Reporter credits the film with “scalding pathos.” TheWrap calls it the series’ most effective balance of crowd-pleasing engagement and sobering commentary yet. Matt Zoller Seitz writes, “They’ll appreciate this movie for not lying to them,” which is a strange compliment for a studio franchise to earn and also the most honest one it has gotten in years.
The book sold 1.5 million copies worldwide in its first week, more than double Snakes and over three times Mockingjay’s, so the built-in audience was never the question. The question was whether the movie could justify 158 minutes to anyone outside that audience, and it cannot. Fans will forgive the length because they know where it is going. Everyone else will feel every minute of the walk.