Gentle Monster is worth a Friday night at home, and the reason fits inside one performance. Léa Seydoux plays Lucy, a concert pianist who moves to the countryside for her husband’s recovery and ends up watching police carry his computers out the front door, and director Marie Kreutzer spends most of the film’s 1 hour 54 minutes simply filming Lucy deciding how much of the truth she can stand to know. It is now streaming on Netflix in the U.S., Canada, the U.K., Australia and New Zealand after a brief theatrical run and a Cannes competition premiere, and the reception, 71 percent on Rotten Tomatoes and a 67 Metascore, is the right split for a movie that refuses to resolve its own case.
That refusal is the whole design. Philip (Laurence Rupp) is tender with their son on Super-8, assembles a trampoline in the yard, and gets arrested for possessing child pornography, and the film never confirms or denies whether the boy was involved. Anyone who wants that question answered, or who is hoping for a legal thriller with a tidy third act, should skip this one now and spare themselves the frustration.
The scene that explains the method best has nothing to do with evidence. Lucy is sent upstairs at the police station for information and only realizes once she’s there that the second floor houses the unit for sexualized violence against children. A floor number does the work a confrontation scene would have oversold, and it’s the sharpest instinct in the film: let the audience arrive at the horror the way Lucy does, a beat behind.
The craft choice that carries Gentle Monster, though, is musical, and Kreutzer and the composer Camille built it cleverly before half-undermining it. Seydoux performs Lucy’s repertoire herself, stripping Charles & Eddie’s “Would I Lie to You?” down to solo piano in the opening scene and later dragging The Cure’s “Boys Don’t Cry” into a slow onstage crawl. These are pop songs written by men, taken apart to see what’s hidden in them, so the film’s argument is already playing before the plot has unpacked a single box. Kreutzer then cuts away from nearly every cover before it finishes, which reads two ways at once: as the denial Lucy is living inside, and as a director declining to hand over the one pleasure she promised (the approach only tips over once, into a literal fork in the road late in the film, which is as unsubtle as Gentle Monster ever gets).
Seydoux’s work here is negotiation rather than grief, a state the film never lets her settle out of. Rupp keeps Philip’s face close to unreadable, the correct choice for a husband whose honesty the movie won’t certify either way, and Jella Haase, as the investigator Elsa, plays professional calm curdling into something closer to a bribe when she offers her father’s abused caretaker more money to stay quiet. Catherine Deneuve, meanwhile, is the film’s smallest surprise and its biggest tease. She gets one terrific line (something to the effect that the only thing worse than having children, for a woman artist, is moving to the countryside) and little else, so viewers expecting a Seydoux-Deneuve two-hander should adjust their expectations accordingly.
Kreutzer’s prior work puts this one in context. Her last feature, Corsage, was Austria’s submission to the Academy Awards and paired the same cold-institution fixation with a wink and a modern needle drop; Gentle Monster drops the wink entirely and stands in the open, bare rooms and pleasant daylight doing work the script leaves unsaid. The project predates the headlines it now seems to answer: Kreutzer started from a newspaper article she read during COVID while prepping Corsage, and a Corsage actor later pleaded guilty to possessing tens of thousands of child sexual abuse files. Her own line about that case, that “we cannot see into the depths of our fellow humans,” could serve as this film’s epigraph.
The Elsa subplot is where the film’s reach outruns its grip, and it’s worth being fair about why it’s there before dismissing it. Kreutzer has said the point was to show that abuse isn’t committed by “the creepy guy behind the bushes,” but by someone already inside the house, and Elsa’s story is meant to double that idea rather than pad the runtime. It mostly works as argument and only partly as drama; the film is reaching for a second case study and lands somewhere closer to a distraction from the first one.
Who will be bored, kindly: anyone who treats a two-hour sit with this subject as a chore rather than an argument, and anyone clicking play expecting momentum instead of a woman negotiating with what she already half knows. The film earns comparison to Kreutzer’s recent run of women absorbing institutional damage, and it sits as her least playful, most exposed entry in that run.
Stream Gentle Monster for Seydoux, who gives one of the more controlled performances of the year, with one qualification: the performance is finished and the movie around it isn’t quite, and that gap is the point Kreutzer is making rather than a flaw in the making of it.