The Movie Opinions Verdict Skip It

Hershey is a skip, and the giveaway is in the credits rather than the reviews: this is a Dandelion Media production made in partnership with the Hershey Entities, meaning The Hershey Company, Milton Hershey School and three of its sister organizations all had a hand in shaping how Milton S. Hershey’s life got told. The company’s own blog post from producer Suzanne Jones calls the film “a strategic content platform,” and once a biography’s own subject is sitting in the producers’ chairs, the conflict that makes a life worth dramatizing tends to go missing. It did here.

What survives the editing is a single idea, deployed once. The film opens with a match cut turning an immaculate chocolate Kiss into a lump of coal, sweetness traced back to something that did not start sweet, and David Ehrlich at IndieWire correctly identifies it as the film’s “first and only stylistic flourish.” Everything after that is competent coverage: Finn Wittrock plays Milton as relentless optimism in a waistcoat, which is the assignment, while Alexandra Daddario’s Kitty is the one performer who looks like she is thinking about something beyond hitting her mark. Even a family-focused reviewer who liked the movie noticed that the clever transitions stop the moment the Kiss finishes becoming coal, which is a polite way of saying the film spends its entire budget of craft in the first ten seconds.

The absence of conflict is not an accident, and the film’s own promotional material admits as much. Angel’s official FAQ concedes that Tobias Thornhill, the one character who functions as an antagonist, is “a fictional composite character created to dramatize the business competition Milton faced”: an authorized film inventing a rival to beat, then clearing him out so nobody real has to look bad. The Titanic stretch is worse. Ehrlich describes a scene where the Hersheys dance for joy over having missed the ship, when the actual paper trail held by the Hershey Community Archives shows Milton cancelling a $300 deposit on a first-class stateroom for business reasons and sailing home early on the German liner Amerika instead. A man doing arithmetic about a hotel deposit is a better scene than a family dancing in relief (it is also, it turns out, the true one).

Mark Waters directed this, and the distance from his best work says most of what needs saying. He made Mean Girls and Freaky Friday, two comedies with real teeth in them, and his recent run includes Mother of the Bride and La Dolce Villa, a trajectory toward gentler and gentler material. Ehrlich notes the film lands “absent any trace of the poppy confidence” that defined that earlier work, and he is not being unkind so much as accurate. What is left is a filmmaker executing someone else’s brief rather than making a choice of his own, and ScreenRant’s Alex Harrison, who gave the film 5 out of 10, landed on the same word for it: frictionless.

None of this will register as a problem for the audience the film was actually built for. Angel’s Guild score sits at 93, the Guild’s own guidance recommends it for viewers 8 and up, and the studio’s recently announced Angel Promise, which bars on-screen sex, nudity and profanity and requires a member score of 70 or better before a title qualifies, a policy Variety reported on last month, is a bar this film clears without strain. Grandparents taking the family out before the turkey, Angel Guild regulars who vote with their subscriptions, and anyone who wanted a biopic that doubles as a wholesome Thanksgiving outing will get exactly what was promised. Anyone who liked a biopic with actual stakes, The Founder included, will spend two hours waiting for somebody on screen to be wrong about something and will leave disappointed.

That release date was not an accident either. Angel’s own FAQ says the Wednesday-before-Thanksgiving slot was chosen because the story “centers on family, gratitude, and giving,” which also happens to be the day David Fincher’s The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth opens in a two-week IMAX exclusive before landing on Netflix on Dec. 23. Anyone mapping the weekend can check what else is worth seeing before that opens or catch up on the trailer and IMAX deal that set expectations for Fincher’s side of the ledger, while Hexed and Focker-in-Law carry their own tracking in the $35-45 million and $30-40 million ranges for that same frame. Hershey was never going to win that weekend on volume, and it is not trying to.

The qualification worth making is that this is obedience rather than cynicism. A couple who could not have children of their own turned a candy fortune into a school for other people’s children, and that is a true story with real weight to it. This film moves the facts across the screen in order, asks nothing difficult of anyone watching, and never once risks the brand it was built to protect. Hershey is smooth and sealed exactly as designed, and the people who wanted it that way will be satisfied; everyone else can skip it and wait for a biopic willing to let its subject be wrong about something.