Victorian Psycho is worth a ticket for one reason, and it happens to be the whole reason the film exists: Maika Monroe finally gets a horror role that uses everything she has been holding back, and the movie wrapped around her is nastier and funnier than a governess-in-peril premise has any right to be.
For a decade Monroe has played the one being hunted, followed through fog in It Follows, watched through a window in Watcher, chased through a doll-maker’s case files in Longlegs. In 1858 she is Winifred Notty, hired to civilize the Pounds children at Ensor House, and the only person in the building anyone should actually fear.
Zachary Wigon cast her for the thing she has always carried and nobody had bothered to point a camera at straight on. “One of the interesting things about Maika is her incredible ability to have a restrained, contained intensity on screen,” he said. “There’s this sense with her screen persona that there’s something very intense going on behind her eyes, in her head, that you’re not able to track.” A movie finally opens the cage.
The best choice in the film is also its first one. Winifred rides toward the manor and turns to address the audience directly, composed and prim, insisting she is the sanest person she has ever met, as IndieWire describes the moment. It is not exposition. It is recruitment.
Mashable called the effect Fleabag-shaped, and that reads right. The manners are immaculate, the confidence is unearned, and the joke lands on everyone in the room except her, which includes the audience that just agreed to be her accomplice.
Monroe built this character down to the mouth. The crooked teeth were her own idea, not the makeup department’s. “I’ve had braces three times now,” she said. “And my teeth are straight, but in the Victorian era, that obviously wouldn’t exist. I also wanted to change my look a little bit and step further away from myself.”
The film has no interest in good taste, which helps it. A severed ear turns up in Winifred’s new quarters and becomes a snack before the household has finished introducing itself, per Variety’s review. Mrs. Pounds chops a scullery maid’s hair off after a strand lands in her soup. Mr. Pounds waves away his daughter’s education with a line Variety quoted straight from the film: “She’s at an age where fertility can be ravaged by over-education.” Ruth Wilson and Jason Isaacs play both Pounds parents as caricatures on purpose and at full volume, which is the only correct read of that assignment.
Wigon’s camera has jokes of its own. Overhead shots turn the manor into a dollhouse, per Rendy Reviews, and he adds keyhole framing, a camera that swings like a pendulum, and one detour from inside something Winifred swallows.
The marketing undersold all of it. Bleecker Street’s trailer leaned on the title and the gimmick instead of the lead who makes the gimmick work.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sDiFol_2j2I
The concession is real, and it matters. The film does not build much suspense, and two critics who liked plenty else about it said so directly. Variety’s Guy Lodge called it “neither frightening nor funny enough to pass muster.” The Hollywood Reporter’s David Rooney filed his review under a bottom line that doubles as a joke at the film’s expense: “We are not amused.”
Those critics and this one are watching the same movie. The disagreement is over what Monroe’s performance is worth against the thinness around it.
By the numbers the business runs on, not quite enough yet. Rotten Tomatoes has it at 74 percent from 97 reviews, with a consensus calling it “an enjoyably blood-soaked lark that thrives on Maika Monroe’s ferocious lead performance.” The audience score sits lower, at 64 percent, flipping the usual horror split. Opening weekend brought $1,081,419 across 1,206 theaters), an average of $897 a screen, with the domestic total reaching $1,344,614 and the worldwide figure $1,945,334 by Nov. 17.
Part of that shortfall predates the movie itself. It was set up at A24 with Margaret Qualley in the role; both exited, Bleecker Street picked it up with cameras about to roll in Ireland, and the release date slid from September 25 to November 13. The site’s opening-day column on Monroe argued she keeps rescuing packages nobody built for her. This film is the strongest case for that argument, and the business around it is the weakest evidence against it.
Who will love this: Monroe’s fans first, then the eat-the-rich horror comedy crowd who liked the country house version of this joke somewhere else and want it with worse manners and a higher body count.
Who should stay home: anyone who wants genuine scares, a clean satire, or a movie that keeps pace with its own lead for the full runtime. The R rating covers strong bloody violence and brief sexual material, and the violence does not discriminate by who deserves it.
The ticket still buys the thing worth buying. A great actor finally gets to be the monster, and the film hands her the knife and gets out of the way for long stretches. That is a good Friday night, and a better argument afterward.