The Movie Opinions Verdict See It in Theaters

Clayface delivers exactly what its trailer promised and then goes further: a lean, gooey, R-rated monster movie where the villain gets the whole runtime and nobody in a cape shows up to share it.

The setup is a Hollywood fable with the names scraped off. Matt Hagen (Tom Rhys Harries) is an actor on the way up, freshly Oscar-nominated, magazine covers, a car waiting outside the premiere. A night out in Gotham ends with him in Mia Torrez’s bed and her boyfriend standing over him with a knife. That boyfriend is Markos Szabo (David Dencik), the city’s reigning crime boss, and what follows is the reason this movie carries an R rating. Joyzine’s Colin Lomas calls it “one of the wince-inducing body horror scenes this side of The Substance,” and the comparison holds. James Watkins does not cut away from it.

That cruelty buys everything that comes after: a ruined face, a dead career, a false story on television, and a man with no recourse in a bought city. Naomi Ackie’s Dr. Caitlyn Corr and her untested nanotech fix the face. Then the nanotech keeps going.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OGO4Mqvo3jI

The best set piece in the movie is not the biggest one. It is Hagen trapped in an airplane lavatory during severe turbulence, trying to cut away skin that has grown over his own eyes. THR’s Frank Scheck calls it “a master class in cinematic tension,” and it earns that line on a locked door and a pair of nail scissors, nothing else.

The climax is louder: Hagen walks into Szabo’s nightclub and fights through the whole roster while swapping faces every couple of seconds. The Maine Campus got the tone right, calling it “beautifully hilarious, especially at the climax of the film where he’s fighting all the mafia goons and changing faces every two seconds.” It is a horror set piece that doubles as a magic trick, and it never stops to explain the rules.

Harries is the whole bet, and he covers it. Variety’s Guy Lodge points out the role went to “a face we don’t yet know by heart,” which is exactly right for a man the film spends two hours erasing and rebuilding. Ackie does the harder job, staying a person when the script needs her to be a device, and Lodge credits her with “more curiosity and conscience than the sexy-scientist archetype typically permits.” Eddie Marsan gets maybe four scenes as Hagen’s manager and steals every one of them, a performance Scheck calls “suitably smarmy.” A two-scene part that justifies a murder is good casting.

What this franchise needed was a movie that did not feel like a trailer for four other movies. It got one. Watkins told ScreenRant the Batman material was limited to art-department Easter eggs, explaining that Hagen has not “yet really reached those levels where he would’ve possibly arrived on Batman’s radar in a really significant way.” At 108 minutes and a $44 million budget, Clayface never asks permission from the rest of the universe. That restraint is the whole trick.

The fair complaint is that there is not much underneath the gristle. Rolling Stone’s David Fear found the experience equivalent to eating a handful of Play-Doh, “and twice as flavorless.” There is a version of this story that costs twice as much, casts a bigger star and says something about fame. This is not that version. It is the cheap, mean, effective one, and it knows it.

The box office backs the bet: a $24 million domestic opening, $43 million worldwide out of the gate, and an A- CinemaScore, a grade almost no horror movie gets. Four weekends in, the film had reached $121.3 million worldwide and was closing in on Supergirl’s entire theatrical run, a movie that cost roughly four times as much to make.

Now the part that should worry anyone who liked it. James Gunn and Peter Safran, the executives who got fired by Skydance on Nov. 6, were reportedly basking in Clayface’s modest success and talking about making more “spooky, slimmed-down DC movies.” That conversation now belongs to Jeremy Latcham, who inherits the whole slate on Dec. 1 with no mandates from Skydance about what to greenlight next. His public comments do the talking for him: Variety sums up his instincts as leaning toward four-quadrant crowdpleasers, built on a test he has described as “I don’t know if my grandma would like that.” He has also pitched a slate meant to “be the HBO for the faith and family audience.” ScreenRant has already guessed this could be DC’s last R-rated movie for a while, and nothing in Latcham’s own words argues against it.

Body horror fans will eat this one up. The Joker crowd, people who wanted a villain’s movie with a villain actually at the center of it, will get what they came for. Anyone squeamish about eye trauma, or anyone bringing kids expecting a Saturday matinee, should stay far away. The gore is not decoration here, it is the plot.

Clayface is a good, nasty, confidently small movie that DC Studios may not know how to make again. See it in a theater while one still wants it.